Tonal Review

The smart gym options we compared

Tonal 2 is the focus of this review. Compare buying, renting and a no-membership alternative before you commit.

Quick verdict

Tonal 2 has the best smart features in home strength training. Garage Gym Reviews scored its smart features 5/5 and value 4/5. Those are the publication's scores, not our ratings or test results.

Buy it if you want a coach on your wall and will use the membership. Skip it if you lift heavy or hate monthly fees. The smart features are the reason to pay more, not a way around the resistance limit.

Specs and price

Tonal 2 launched in January 2025. It offers 5 to 250 lb of digital resistance, with 125 lb per arm and 1 lb steps. The 24 in 4K touchscreen sits on a unit measuring 50.9 in high by 21.5 in wide, extending 5.5 in off the wall.

Its Smart View camera has a 120 degree view. Tonal 2 uses 17 sensors to track form, pace and range of motion. Garage Gym Reviews lists 315+ movements. Training modes include Spotter, Eccentric, Chains, Burnout and Drop Set.

As of October 18, 2026, Tonal 2 costs $4,295. The bundle with Smart Accessories, delivery and install lists at $5,085, plus membership. The Essentials accessories bundle is $495 for 7 accessories. The Ultimate bundle is $595 for 9 accessories and adds Pilates loops and ankle straps.

Delivery and installation start at $295. Your final cost appears at checkout. Delivery takes 1 to 4 weeks after ordering. Financing is available over 36 months through Affirm. Tonal lists HSA/FSA eligibility through Truemed for qualified customers. Prices change often.

Tonal Rent is $279/month plus a $49 setup fee. It includes a new or like-new Tonal 2, the Essential Accessories Bundle, membership, white-glove delivery and installation. You can cancel and return anytime. Tonal ran a first-month-free rental promo through November 1, 2026 for qualified buyers. Credit approval is needed.

Real cost

Here is the first-year math using the Essentials accessories and starting installation price: $4,295 + $495 accessories + $295 install + $719.40 membership (12 x $59.95) = about $5,804. That is about $5,800 before any membership tax or higher installation charge.

After year one, membership is $719.40 per year before tax. Garage Gym Reviews also says the total cost will exceed $5,000. Judge Tonal by the full bill, not just the machine price.

Membership: what it costs and why it matters

Tonal says each purchase requires a 12-month commitment at $59.95/month plus tax. One membership covers unlimited accounts in your home. The fee belongs in your budget from the start.

The appeal is guided training with weight selection and form feedback. Buy it if you want that coaching and will use it. If you want no monthly fee, compare the Speediance Gym Monster 2.

What we like

• AI sets and adjusts weight so you can focus on training.
• The Smart View 120 degree camera gives form feedback.
• Spotter, Eccentric, Chains, Burnout and Drop Set modes add training options.
• The wall-mounted machine has no floor footprint.
• One membership covers unlimited user profiles in your home.

What could be better

• The required membership raises your long-term cost.
• Professional wall mounting needs proper studs and can be hard for renters.
• The 250 lb cap limits heavy squats and deadlifts.
• Accessories, installation and membership make the total cost high.
• Trail and Kale notes that Spotter can trigger too early if the delay is set too short.

Tonal 2 vs Tonal 1

Tonal 2 raises max resistance from 200 lb to 250 lb. It adds the Smart View camera and better sound. Aero HIIT cardio-strength workouts are available on Tonal 2 only.

Movements went from 310 to 315+, per Garage Gym Reviews. The main reasons to choose Tonal 2 are more resistance, form feedback from the camera and the added workouts.

Tonal 2 vs Speediance Gym Monster 2

Tonal 2 has 30 lb more resistance and stays off the floor. Speediance is cheaper, folds away and needs no membership or wall mounting. The Gym Monster 2 offers 220 lb total, or 110 lb per arm, and folds to about 2.7 sq ft.

Speediance sale prices were $3,239 to $3,387 when checked on October 17, 2026. Tonal 2 is $4,295 plus the required membership. Read our Speediance review for the other side of this choice. For a full side-by-side, see Speediance vs Tonal.

Will it fit in your garage?

Plan for 7 ft of open wall, 7 ft x 7 ft of floor space and a 7 ft 10 in ceiling. You need a 3-prong outlet within 6 ft and reliable Wi-Fi. Installation is professional only, and the wall needs proper studs.

A cold or damp garage needs some climate control. Our garage heating guide covers that part of the setup. Put rubber flooring in your training area and compare options in our best home gym flooring guide. For electrical or structural work, follow local codes and use a licensed pro.

Who should buy it, and who should skip it

Buy Tonal 2 if you are busy, train at a beginner to intermediate level and want guided plans. It also suits you if you are short on space and can mount it properly. Our garage gym ideas can help you plan the room.

Skip it if you are a heavy barbell lifter. A power rack with free weights is a better fit. Compare adjustable dumbbells and our best home gym equipment guide before spending on a smart gym.

It is also a poor fit for renters who cannot wall-mount and budget buyers who want to avoid monthly fees.

Warranty and returns

Tonal includes a 2-year limited warranty. Extended coverage costs $425 for 4 years or $449 for 5 years. Purchases come with a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Frequently asked questions